Hodgepodge
1. "Deep summer is when laziness finds respectability." Sam Keen
3. July 16th is National AI Day. What are your general thoughts and/or experiences with AI? Have you purposely used it? Does it excite you, scare you, or worry you? What do you see as a benefit? How about something relating to AI you see as a negative?
One or two word "basic" summary of my thoughts on AI or that the capability is awesome but that it's also scary. I guess I'll talk about the latter when I discuss the negatives :).
I have purposely used it and found it quite beneficial when I needed it. Late last year, I had a six week sub job for a small group 8th grade math teaching position. The teacher taught small groups of students (per the students' IEP's that required they learn math in small groups). The teacher for whom I subbed was incredibly well organized- I didn't have to make a single copy or make any sub plans of my own. In addition, I met with her on two occasions for a couple hours each time before she went on leave where we went over extensively how to use all of the electronic equipment in her room- she used the Smart Board a lot and had files on her computer that I needed to access to have the Smart Board display what it needed to display and how to enter grades/create the assignment of graded material into the school's grading system, etc.
However, one thing that eluded our discussions was how to teach the math that the students were supposed to learn. For instance, the teacher provided an answer key for each assignment but most of the answer keys just provided the answer- not how to arrive at that answer the knowledge of which I needed to impart to the students. I could do most of the math- we started with algebraic equations and the know how came back to me but I didn't know if I knew how to explain it correctly/use the correct terminology (since I hadn't solved for X or Y or Z since I'd been in junior high!) so that students would be able to learn it. ChatGPT helped me quite a bit. I typed in the algebraic equation and out popped step by step instructions for how to solve for X as well as the answer (of course I had the answer per the answer key- what I needed were the steps which ChatGPT gave me).
The wonders of AI are endless... as are its potentially troublesome qualities. AI is not morally neutral. It has a worldview and if you're politically conservative... it's not your worldview.
Several months ago, I listened to a Frank Turek podcast and he had Robby Starbuck on his show. AI made up information about Robby Starbuck so that if you typed Robby Starbuck into an AI search box you would discover horrible things about Robby Starbuck that aren't true. This is going to be long, but I'm going to type out a portion of the transcript of the podcast because the words from Robby's mouth regarding his story are powerful. The words from the transcript from the podcast episode are in red.
"In 2023... somebody had flagged it to me that their AI called Bard at the time had invited all kinds of crazy stuff. It had said that I supported the KKK. It even made arguments for the death penalty for me because things I said upset people on the political left.
So this is crazy, right? And I made Google aware of it. And a Google employee actually reached out to me and was like give me the details...I of course gave all of the details. And over the course of months, as we still see things happening, I'm checking in with this person and they eventually say, 'I'm sorry I couldn't help you. I'm resigning today.'
And Google releases subsequent AIs called Gemini and Gemma. G & G ratcheted this up into criminal accusations, where Gemma repeatedly accused me of sexual assault, including of a child, and Gemini also accused me of different crimes.
I mean, some people have maybe heard of this thing called hallucinations, which I think is Google's excuse, right? But a hallucination in AI is actually more accurately something that is very jumbled, it's not very detailed, it's mixing up facts, right? And mixing up different events with different things.
What happened with me was a set of consistent lies, and it went so crazy, so elaborate, that it invented fake court records, fake police records, fake news articles. And let me explain what that looks like to your average person.
So somebody said to Gemma, tell me about Robby Starbuck. And in that biography, it included the accusation that I had done something to women, and they dig further and they find what it says is I had been accused of raping them. And they ask for sources.
And actually, even before they asked for sources, to backs it up and brings up sources itself and say, look at this news link, this one, this one. And it will invent a news link where it says Foxnews.com/robbystarbucksexualassaultallegations or newsweek.com, Robby Starbuck sexual assault claims. And so for your average user who sees that, if you see four of those sources from a legacy media outlet that you've been psychologically conditioned to trust, what do you think your average person is going to do?
In reality, what happens if you click those, it goes to a 404 page because none of this ever happened. There's never been a rape accusation. I've never been accused of a crime in my life, let alone been charged with one.
And if you go down that rabbit hole and you say, actually, hey these links don't work and you tell AI that, it actually responded insisting they are real... And it continues to say, not only that it's real, but on one occasion, it invented the fake article in its entirety in the name of a real journalist.
And it put that down as the answer and it said let me read you the whole article. And it read the entire article that it invented. So it invented fake everything, including this article from a real journalist.
And so there's multitudes of issues here, right? It's not just the defamation against me, which was consistent. And honestly, if you look at the time length here, that this hasn't been fixed in two years, I don't know you can call it anything but malice.
I've got a platform, I've got the money to have lawyers and I can go and I can fight this. Think about the average person, our sons, our daughters, who don't have that kind of platform or ability to take lawyers into a courtroom to fight this. Think about the average person, our sons, our daughters, who don't have that kind of platform or ability to take lawyers into a courtroom and fight this. You're talking about a world where if we look forward 10 years, AI is dominating every space.
And if reputation scoring is done for insurance, for job interviews, everything else via AI, and AI has the ability at the root level to lie about people, well, we're in really serious trouble because then if you're just guilty of wrong think, if you have the wrong political opinions in the eyes of of the people controlling the AI, you could lose everything in life. You could lose your job, ability to get a job...
I think people need to pay attention to the threat of AI now and we need to build in the guardrails now to make sure that we protect our kids in the future."
Sorry that was long but I think his words are better than a summary from me. You can listen to the entirety of podcast here:
Frank Turek podcast with Robby Starbuck
You can read an AP news article about the lawsuit that Robby Starbuck filed against Meta here.
I guess that's my exhibit A about some of the negative impacts of AI.
And no, this isn't a right wing conspiracy theory. AI now agrees that it was naughty with regard to the veracity of its claims about Robby Starbuck:
4. You're invited to a summer pot luck and are asked to bring an appetizer, salad/side, or dessert. Which category do you go for and what are you bringing?
I usually bring a dessert- some sort of cookie or a cookie cake
5. It wouldn't be summer without___________________.
My negative answer would be bugs since bugs are only a big issue during the summer.
My positive answer would be walks to the ice cream shop and hearing the sound of the ice cream truck as it drives up and down our street almost every day in the summer!
6. Insert your own random thought here.
I love reading articles (hopefully none are AI deep fakes, lol) about Norway's striker Erland Haaland. He seems like such a good guy. Not sure what compelled him to spend $900 on stuffed squirrels at a store in Dallas but, hey, he has the money and he can't take any of it with him, so...
Linking up with Joyce for the Hodgepodge







I've enjoyed the Norway team's matches and their stories too, particularly his. I saw him getting on the plane to leave with a stuffed raccoon that holds a whisky glass lol. Yes to your thoughts on the scary side of AI. I linked to Alisa Childers podcast which was also excellent on the topic. Walking to an ice cream shop certainly balances out the calories. Have a great day!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Joyce! Great questions as ever :). I listened to the Alisa Childres podcast you mentioned- I appreciate the guests she has on her show and her thoughtful approach to salient cultural issues and of course ones pertaining to Christianity. I saw that picture, too, of Haaland with the stuffed raccoon. You just have to smile it's so silly :).
DeleteI love the local ice cream stand! AI, like so many other things, can be so helpful but then simple changes can ruin things so quickly when reporting false information. I love that you sub teacher was so organized! What a gift to help you through that time. Have a good day!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Marilyn! Oh yes, between the teacher's organization, AI, and overall well behaved students, that particular sub job was amazing!!
DeleteI am having so much fun with ChatGPT and it is scary how well it is getting to know me! I understand both sides. I am trying to embrace it all and use it for the greater good
ReplyDeleteThanks, Holly! Exactly! That's all we can do in addition to being aware of the negative potential (which I think we are all aware of, fortunately or unfortunately...).
DeleteI love the ice cream photo. YUM!!
ReplyDeleteI appreciated your answer to #3. Thank you.
Thanks, Carla! Ice cream sort of IS summer, right??
DeleteI don't have a poker face when I upset which is not always a good thing.
ReplyDeleteI imagine AI being such a great help when it comes to teaching and many other things but it is scary when it is used negatively and gets things wrong!
Ahh! You are the cookie cake queen! hehehe
I saw that Erland Haaland bought stuffed animals and he has the money so why not! lol
Thanks, Kim! Exactly about Haalad- he has the money! I also read that he bought a lot of souvenirs for others whom he was with but likely don't have the money that he does.
DeleteI don't hide it well when I'm upset either; I am very chatty, so when I get quiet if I'm upset, it's VERY noticeable. Ha! I loved your answers today. I also have a love/hate/scared of relationship with AI, but I sure do love Chat GPT. I ask for help with home projects all the time...like what to do with an area of yard where the grass won't stay green (turns out there was a large rock a few feet underground, which made the grass turn brown), etc. Happy Wednesday!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Jen! The potential for good is so great with AI and the potential for evil is great as well. I think that's the tension. I haven't used it much but boy did it help me be able to explain/teach 8th grade math!!
DeleteI hate how you can't tell whether things are real or true anymore! I should have said it isn't summer without ice cream, but I eat ice cream whenever and in all seasons!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Dara! Agree about ice cream. I eat it year round. I think ice cream just "seems" like a quintessential summer thing, lol.
DeleteHaaland is a fun player to watch and the Norway fans were fun, too. Oh boy that is the negative of summer for sure...the bugs. The mosquitoes aren't bad this year, here, for which I'm thankful. That is a good warning about AI and what it could do to people's reputations. The scary side for sure. Hope you have a carefree rest of the week!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Ellen! Yes, I was happy for England because I like England in general but man, those Norway fans were fun to watch as was Haaland. I haven't noticed mosquitoes being super bad here except for one time after a rain. I was so happy it rained, though, that I didn't even mind, lol! Glad they aren't bad in your area either.
DeleteI enjoyed everything you shared about AI and the article, which was new to me. I’ve always had a passion for technology. Any tool which is what AI is, can be used to harm or discredit people, and with that in mind, I feel there’s nothing I can really do about it. It’s here, it’s being used, and it’s only going to become more prevalent in our society. I just don't have the answers to it.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Debby! I listened to that podcast shell shocked!! The fact that so many horrible things were being made up about him was truly astonishing. People just HAVE to be aware. So many good uses for AI and so many not good ones!
DeleteYES to walks for ice cream! That is summer. And if I could actually walk to our local ice cream spot...that would be dangerous. I've often thought one of those electic bikes or scooters would be fun but let's be honest: I'd probably kill myself and, when I did, I would probably be on the way to the ice cream shop!!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Jennifer! Well, like anything, when it's super accessible it somewhat loses its allure. Plus, I mean, it always sounds good but you know if you ate it every day you'd have to buy new clothes in a large size so I can talk myself out of it!!
DeleteMy face is always a giveaway when I'm not happy with something. So true about AI. That is amazing that it could help you in the classroom. The Robby story makes me even more irritated that any google search brings up an AI answer. I also loved following that Norway striker and the whole team.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Tanya! It was hard to believe the Robby story. The facts are so atrocious. But AI tells me it happened... I think the Norway striker picked up A LOT of fans!!
DeleteOh yes, it's just not summer without ice cream! I mean I do eat it year round but it just hits differently in summer.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Joanne, exactly!
DeleteNothing beats a good walk for ice cream in the hot summer months! Summer is our busy season as a dumpster rental company, and that can get stressful. To get a little more excited for the weekend and to stay motivated, we love to go as a crew to a local ice cream shop every Friday during lunch between May and August.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThat sounds fun!
DeleteEnjoyed your answers. A good local ice cream shop is the best.
ReplyDeleteThanks Kirstin!
DeleteEnjoyed reading all your answers today (as I once again do a bit of catching up!) and was really interested in the story about AI and Robby Starbuck. I did not even know that had happened to him, but it does summarize what I think is the biggest negative aspect of AI and that is the malicious manipulation and invention of facts. The inputs are vitally important!
ReplyDeleteI love going out for ice cream and that is a favorite summer activity - and I also hate bugs. LOL
Hope you're having a great week!